
It has taken over 400 years, but the identity of the mysterious Dark Lady of Shakespeare’s sonnets can finally be revealed – she is a Venetian courtesan called Virginia Padoana
Probably, more nonsense has been talked and written, more intellectual and emotional energy expended in vain, on the sonnets of Shakespeare than on any other literary work in the world
W. H. Auden
Few mysteries in Shakespeare scholarship have proved as enduring, or as intriguing, as the identity of the woman traditionally known as the Dark Lady of the Sonnets. She is the third member of a highly sexualised ménage à trois involving Shakespeare, the Dark Lady, and a man known as the ‘Fair Youth’.
Despite the best investigative efforts, her identity has remained entirely elusive. However, my previous research showing that (a) Shakespeare was in Italy in 1587; (b) his sonnet sequence, published in 1609, was connected to the Virginia Company’s expedition of that year; and (c) a certain William Hole not only procured the sonnets for publication, but was also commissioned to engrave the map of Virginia, led me, via an English spy, to a Venetian courtesan called Virginia Padoana.
This pOSTwill show how I assembled several ‘neglected items in the biographical gallimaufry’, as Leslie Hotson calls them, into a cohesive picture which suggests that Virginia Padoana is at least the leading candidate among the courtesans of the cultural demimonde of the Veneto region, from which the Dark Lady must have sprung. The solution involves numerous threads, woven together into a large tapestry, which essentially tells us the following.
The Dark Lady sequence, generally identified as Sonnets 127–152, contains some of Shakespeare’s most passionate, disturbing and psychologically complex poetry. Yet the sequence is not simply a collection of poems addressed to a mistress. Beneath its themes of desire, jealousy, betrayal and deception lies the suggestion of a complicated emotional relationship involving three people. It is in sonnets 135 and 136 that we get the punning inside info on the two love rivals, both of which are called Will – .ie. William Shakespeare & William Stanley.
Sonnet 135
Whoever hath her wish, thou hast thy Will,
And Will to boot, and Will in overplus;
More than enough am I that vex’d thee still,
To thy sweet will making addition thus.
Sonnet 136
If thy soul check thee that I come so near,
Swear to thy blind soul that I was thy Will,
And will, thy soul knows, is admitted there;
Thus far for love, my love-suit, sweet, fulfil.
Identifying the third member of the ménage à trois — the Dark Lady — has become something of a giant game of Guess Who? The process begins, however, with a substantial narrowing of the field: recognising the cultural compatibility of Venetian courtesans with the woman portrayed in the Sonnets. In Venice, courtesans (cortigiane) occupied a unique and highly visible social stratum. While public prostitutes (meretrici) were heavily restricted, elite courtesans (cortigiane oneste) lived lavishly, wore the finest silks, and imitated — or even dictated — the fashion trends of patrician brides and noblewomen. Their education, literary accomplishments, musical abilities, wit, independence, and power to attract and enchant men provide a compelling context for understanding Shakespeare’s Dark Lady, who is also witty, musical, strong-willed, and possessed of a magnetic sexual allure that captivates the speaker despite his better judgement. Indeed, her power over him is such that he is prompted to call her his ‘female evil’ and his ‘bad angel’.

Business transactions: the courtesan as an economic agent
Shakespeare’s Dark Lady is repeatedly associated with money, financial obligation and commercial exchange. The language of the sonnets suggests a relationship in which affection and sexual intimacy are entangled with material considerations. In Sonnet 142, the expression “beds’ revenues” is especially suggestive.
That have profaned their scarlet ornaments
And sealed false bonds of love as oft as mine,
Robbed others’ beds’ revenues of their rents.
Sonnet 146 offers another intriguing possibility:
Painting thy outward walls so costly gay?
Why so large cost, having so short a lease,
Dost thou upon thy fading mansion spend?
The imagery of costly decoration, expenditure and a short lease is striking. The body is represented as a temporary property, its outward appearance maintained at considerable expense. The language may suggest a woman who invests heavily in her appearance because her beauty is central to her livelihood. The reference to a “short lease” also introduces the question of how long such an investment can remain profitable.
Perhaps the strongest commercial imagery occurs in Sonnets 133 and 134, where Shakespeare develops an elaborate vocabulary of financial and legal obligation. In Sonnet 134, he writes:
And I myself am mortgaged to thy will.
The poem proceeds through the language of forfeiture, surety, bonds, statutes, usury and debt, ending:
He pays the whole, and yet am I not free.
This is an extraordinary extension of the commercial metaphor. The speaker is not simply emotionally attached to the woman; he describes himself as financially encumbered by her.
Thomas Coryat’s account of Venice provides contemporary evidence that courtesans could be financially assertive and commercially independent. He warns his readers that a man who enjoys a courtesan’s company without paying what he has promised may face serious consequences:
“Shee will either cause thy throate to be cut by her Rurfiano […] or procure thee to be arrested […] and clapped up in the prison, where thou shalt remaine till thou hast paid her all thou didst promise her.”
Whatever the exaggeration in Coryat’s warning, the underlying point is important: the courtesan could regard payment as a contractual obligation and pursue a client who failed to honour it. This provides an interesting social context for Shakespeare’s repeated use of commercial and legal language when describing his mistress.
Cosmetics: artificial beauty and the Venetian courtesan

As Farah Karim-Cooper discusses in her study Deceived with Ornament: Shakespeare’s Venice, Venice was an important centre of cosmetic production and consumption. Its commercial connections made it a major source of imported beauty products, including hair dyes, oils and perfumes. Venetian ceruse was also reputed to be of particularly high quality. William Thomas, in The History of Italy, also comments on Venetian women’s use of cosmetics, observing that their natural appearance could be difficult to judge because of their painting. Elsewhere, John Bulwer, in Anthropometamorphosis, observes:
“The ladies of Italy (not to speak of the Curtezans) to seem fairer than the rest, take a pride to besmear and paint themselves.”
These accounts establish that artificial beauty was a recognised feature of Italian feminine fashion, particularly in discussions of Venetian women. Shakespeare introduces the Dark Lady, however, through a rejection of these conventional standards of beauty:
In the old age black was not counted fair,
Or if it were, it bore not beauty’s name;
But now is black beauty’s successive heir,
And beauty slandered with a bastard shame.
He continues:
For since each hand hath put on Nature’s power,
Fairing the foul with Art’s false borrowed face
The reference to “Art’s false borrowed face” is particularly important. Shakespeare suggests that women are increasingly altering their natural appearance through artificial means. Beauty has become something manufactured rather than inherited from nature.
The practice was sufficiently familiar to attract criticism from contemporary writers. In Pietro Aretino’s I Ragionamenti, a courtesan advises her daughter against excessive cosmetics, mocking women who cover their faces with paint and powder in an attempt to conceal wrinkles and other imperfections. Similarly, The Book of the Courtier ridicules women whose foundation is so thick that they appear to be wearing masks.
Shakespeare turns to the subject of artificial beauty in The Merchant of Venice, when Bassanio reflects on the deceptive nature of outward appearance:
Look on beauty,
And you shall see ’tis purchased by the weight,
Which therein works a miracle in nature,
Making them lightest that wear most of it.
He also describes artificial hair:
So are those crispèd snaky golden locks,
Which maketh such wanton gambols with the wind
Upon supposed fairness, often known
To be the dowry of a second head.
The passage is a striking criticism of cosmetic artifice, false hair and manufactured beauty. Its setting in Venice makes the comparison particularly relevant to the city’s reputation for elaborate personal adornment.
Dark hair and Eyes
Shakespeare’s repeated references to dark eyes, black hair and artificial beauty are particularly interesting when considered against the cosmetic practices of Renaissance Venice. Venetian women were renowned for lightened, golden and reddish hair. Thomas Coryat, writing in Coryat’s Crudities (1611), gives a detailed account of Venetian women’s hair preparations:
All the women of Venice every Saturday in the afternoon do use to anoint their hair with oil, or some other drugs, to the end to make it look fair, that is whitish, for that colour is most affected of the Venetian dames and lasses.
Michel de Montaigne also recorded the Venetian fashion for blonde hair, describing women sitting on rooftops with their hair spread out in the sun after applying various preparations. Light hair was not universal, however, with some courtesans on occasion creating dark eyes, hair and eyebrows through cosmetics. A study of the sonnets reveals that the darkness of the Dark Lady darkness seems cosmetically induced. In Sonnet 127, Shakespeare writes:
Therefore my mistress’ eyes are raven black,
Her eyes so suited, and they mourners seem
At such who, not born fair, no beauty lack,
Sland’ring creation with a false esteem.
& in Love’s Labour’s Lost (4.3)
O, if in black my lady’s brows be deck’d,
It mourns that painting and usurping hair
Should ravish doters with a false aspect;
And therefore is she born to make black fair.
The Venetian physician Giovanni Marinello’s Gli ornamenti delle donne (1562) provides valuable contemporary evidence of the cosmetic culture. Its recipes include preparations for colouring women’s eyes and eyebrows. One recipe, transcribed by modern scholars, describes a preparation using antimony, lapis lazuli, musk, camphor, aloe wood and saffron. Applied to the eyes at night, it promised that they would appear black and beautiful the following morning, as though naturally so
Red Lipstick: cosmetics and the Venetian courtesan
Shakespeare’s reference to his mistress’s lips in Sonnet 142 is particularly suggestive when read alongside the cosmetic practices of Renaissance Venice:
Or if it do, not from those lips of thine,
That have profaned their scarlet ornaments
The phrase “scarlet ornaments” has been glossed as a reference to lipstick. There is unusually specific contemporary evidence for this cosmetic practice in Giovanni Marinello’s Gli ornamenti delle donne (Venice, 1562), fol. 137v. Marinello gives a recipe for colouring the lips:
“di questa composizione ne bagnerete li labri, che parranno rubini.”
That is:

“With this composition you will moisten the lips, which will appear like rubies.”
The preparation includes murex shell, chard, brazilwood, kermes, alum and rosewater. Elena Lazzarini discusses and translates this recipe in her study, “Giovanni Marinello: Cosmetic Recipes (1562),” pp. 222–227, especially p. 225 and note 20.
Other contemporary descriptions associate red-painted lips with the elaborate cosmetic practices of women in the courtesan world. Castiglione’s The Book of the Courtier (1528), for example, mocks women who whiten their faces and apply thick red pigment to their lips, making their appearance resemble a carnival mask.
Bad Breath
In Sonnet 130, Shakespeare writes of his mistress:
“And in some perfumes is there more delight
Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks.”
This unflattering description has an interesting parallel in contemporary Venetian literature. In Lorenzo Venier’s satirical poem La Puttana Errante (c.1531), an old prostitute is described as having only four teeth and:
“Pute ’l suo fiato più ch’otto conventi”
(Her breath stinks more than eight convents.)
The association between prostitutes, decaying teeth and foul breath also appears in the Venetian Tariffa delle Puttane. Describing the prostitute Bigòla, the poem complains:
“Né vi giovan gl’impiastri e ’l farsi i denti
Spesso purgar, ond’esce il fiato amaro”
(Neither poultices nor having the teeth repeatedly cleaned help her; from them comes the bitter breath.)
There is also evidence of the importance attached to remedies. In the Experimenti attributed to Caterina Sforza (d.1509), a collection of recipes for beauty and bodily care, one preparation is specifically intended to sweeten the breath:
“A fare odorare la bocca et el fiato”
(To make the mouth and breath smell sweet.)
The recipe uses citron peel, nutmeg, cloves and sage, powdered and mixed with wine to make small balls, taken before and after meals. Another preparation uses aromatic rosemary ash to clean and whiten the teeth.
These sources give an intriguing cultural context for Shakespeare’s unusually unromantic description of his mistress in Sonnet 130.
Damask roses: Sonnet 130 and the Venetian courtesan

Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130 is particularly interesting because it may contain a visual reference to the clothing of the Venetian courtesan. The crucial lines are:
“I have seen roses damasked, red and white,
But no such roses see I in her cheeks.”
The word ‘damask’ evokes not only the variegated colouring of roses, but also damask silk, a richly patterned fabric used in fashionable clothing. Yet there may be a further dimension to the imagery.
Thomas Coryat’s account of Venetian courtesans, published in 1611, brings together precisely the two images found in Shakespeare’s lines: the red and white rose of female complexion and the luxurious damask gown. Describing the appearance of a Venetian courtesan, Coryat writes:
“In her cheekes thou shalt see the Lilly and the Rose strive for the supremacy…”
He then describes her elaborate appearance, including her jewellery, ornaments and clothing. Of the dress worn by the more distinguished courtesans, he writes:
“A gowne of damaske (I speake this of the nobler Cortizans) either decked with a deep gold fringe […] or laced with five or sixe gold laces each two inches broade.”
Shakespeare’s expression, therefore, “roses damasked, red and white”, may therefore do more than describe the colouring of a woman’s complexion. It may evoke the floral patterns of the damask gowns worn by Venetian courtesans, bringing together the woman’s physical.
False swearing: the Dark Lady and the Venetian courtesan
Shakespeare repeatedly portrays the Dark Lady as a woman whose words cannot be trusted. Her beauty attracts men, but her promises of love are compromised by deception, infidelity and the ability to maintain several relationships at once. This is a portrait that has interesting parallels with contemporary descriptions of the Venetian courtesan. In Sonnet 142, he writes:
Or if it do, not from those lips of thine,
That have profaned their scarlet ornaments
And sealed false bonds of love as oft as mine,
Robbed others’ beds’ revenues of their rents.
The language is striking. Her lips, already associated with cosmetic artifice, have “sealed false bonds of love”. The metaphor suggests promises made and broken, while the reference to the revenues of other men’s beds gives her sexual relationships an unmistakably commercial dimension.
Here, “Several plot” means an enclosed, privately owned piece of land — something belonging exclusively to one person – while, “The wide world’s common place” means common or public ground, accessible to everyone. Pure courtesan behaviour. The next two lines show how Shakespeare is deliberately deceiving himself about her sexual conduct.
Thomas Coryat’s warning about Venetian women provides a revealing contemporary parallel. In Coryat’s Crudities (1611), he advises his readers:
As for thine eyes, shut them and turne them aside from these venereous Venetian objects. For they are the double windowes that conveigh them to thy heart. Also thou must fortifie thine eares against the attractive inchauntments of their plausible speeches.
Coryat warns against both the visual attraction of Venetian women and their persuasive speech. His description is particularly interesting beside Shakespeare’s portrayal in sonnet 138 of a mistress whose appearance and words repeatedly deceive her lover.
When my love swears that she is made of truth,
I do believe her though I know she lies,
That she might think me some untutored youth,
Unlearned in the world’s false subtleties.
Thus vainly thinking that she thinks me young,
Although she knows my days are past the best,
Simply I credit her false-speaking tongue:
On both sides thus is simple truth suppressed.
The second stanza here is interesting. Shakespeare admits to being young, but also that his ‘days are past the best.’ I would say this is a reflection on the Elizabethan obsession with smooth-skinned, facial-hairless boyish beauty. A scholarly study by Silvia Bigliazzi, Whose Beauty and Whose Shape, examines the successive versions of the Romeo and Juliet story before Shakespeare. In the Italian and English versions, Romeo is described as approximately 20 or 21 years old. The study identifies a particularly revealing passage in Painter’s The Palace of Pleasure (1567). Romeo is described as: “of the age of xx. or xxi. yeres”, and as: “the fairest and best conditioned Gentleman that was amongs the Veronian youth”.
The study also notes that Arthur Brooke’s earlier English poem, The Tragical History of Romeus and Juliet (1562), emphasises Romeo’s lack of obvious masculine characteristics, particularly his beard. This gives us a contemporary literary example of a man two years younger than Shakespeare being celebrated for his youthful beauty. Indeed, the Grafton portrait of Shakespeare shows him with a bit of bumfluff on his face only a year after my purported meeting of him with Virginia Padoana.

Another important clue comes via sonnet 137:
Why should my heart think that a several plot,
Which my heart knows the wide world’s common place?
Or mine eyes, seeing this, say this is not,
To put fair truth upon so foul a face?
Here, “Several plot” means an enclosed, privately owned piece of land — something belonging exclusively to one person – while, “The wide world’s common place” means common or public ground, accessible to everyone. Pure courtesan behaviour. The next two lines show how Shakespeare is deliberately deceiving himself about her sexual conduct.
The flock: the courtesan, her admirers and the child
In Sonnet 143 Shakespeare presents the Dark Lady as a woman whose attention is divided between competing objects of desire. She is compared to a housewife who puts down her baby and rushes after one of her escaped birds:
Lo, as a careful housewife runs to catch
One of her feather’d creatures broke away,
Sets down her babe, and makes all swift dispatch
In pursuit of the thing she would have stay
The speaker identifies himself with the abandoned infant. While the woman pursues what escapes her, he follows her, crying for attention:
So runn’st thou after that which flies from thee,
Whilst I thy babe chase thee afar behind
The comparison becomes especially suggestive when set beside Sir Stephen Powle’s description of Prudencia Romana in Venice in 1587:
“Prudencia Romana with hir courtly trayne of frenche gentlemen euery nighte goeth a spasso … by my Pergalo.”
Prudencia moves through Venice with a following of gentlemen. She is the centre of a male entourage, just as the celebrated courtesan could attract a circle of admirers competing for her company. Matteo Bandello’s account, discussed in modern scholarship, offers a more intimate example: a Venetian courtesan whose established lovers each had an appointed night, while other men sought admission to her favour.
The contrast is striking: the courtesan has her flock, but Shakespeare makes himself the dependent child among her admirers. The sonnet transforms the spectacle of men following a desirable woman into a personal drama of jealousy, competition and emotional dependence. Indeed, in the following image, we can also see how male admirers are represented as chickens.

Jan Vojtech Kulík, památník, paint on paper, 1594. Čislo: ANM, st. sign. II A 4, fo. 176. Archive of the Czech National Museum, Prague.
Erotic skill: Sonnets 150 and 151
In Sonnet 150 Shakespeare suggests that the Dark Lady possesses a remarkable power to excite and retain his love, through what appears to be professional abilities.
In the very refuse of thy deeds
There is such strength and warrantise of skill,
That, in my mind, thy worst all best exceeds.
The language of “skill” is particularly suggestive. His question, “Who taught thee”, invites the possibility that her ability to arouse desire has been learned and practised.
Sonnet 151 makes the physical dimension of this attraction explicit. The speaker describes his body responding to her name:
My soul doth tell my body that he may
Triumph in love; flesh stays no farther reason,
But rising at thy name doth point out thee
As his triumphant prize.
And the sonnet ends:
for whose dear love I rise and fall.
The sexual double meaning is unmistakable. His body acts independently of reason, responding to the woman with an erection and surrendering to desire. The language of triumph and defeat makes their relationship one in which she has extraordinary power over him. In Sonnet 141 Shakespeare makes clear that the speaker is completely infatuated:
In faith I do not love thee with mine eyes,
For they in thee a thousand errors note
Does the “thousand” perhaps refer to the number of sexual partners the Dark Lady has had? If she was a Venetian courtesan, that would be a perfectly truthful statement, as would comparing her to ‘the bay where all men ride’ in sonnet 137. The word ‘bay’ obviously has maritime connections, but for me it also means that parting of the legs which create a bay-like shape.
VIRGINIA PADOANA
VIRGINIA PADOANA
It was while reading the 1587 Venetian correspondence of Sir Stephen Powle, that I was drawn to a courtesan named Virginia Padoana. Her surname suggests that she originated in Padua, in northern Italy, but her professional career as a courtesan was conducted in the region’s capital: Venice, that floating pleasure palace, resplendent in its imperial pomp.
In regards to my research on the Shakespeare-Stanley ‘Grand Tour’, several details immediately caught my attention. The first is a potential play on words between Virginia Padoana & the virgin ‘Portia,’ a strong female character in the ‘Merchant of Venice,’ that without being an actual Courtesan, still possesses many of the intellectual trappings attributed to them.
The second suggestion from Sir Stephen Powle that Virginia was the Dark Lady comes from her Anglophilic praise of English aristocrats. In a letter written by Powle from Venice to John Chamberlain on 21 September 1587, he describes several Venetian courtesans, including Isabella Bellochia, Lodovica Gonzaga and Virginia Padoana. Of the latter, Powle writes:
“And Virginia Padoana, that honoureth all our nation for my Lord of Oxfords sake, is my neighbour on the lefte side.”
This is a particularly revealing observation. Virginia evidently held the English nation in high regard because of the Earl of Oxford, Edward de Vere, who had travelled extensively in Italy in 1575–76, spending considerable time in Venice. The reasoning therefore is this – if Virginia Padoana adored one English earl, then she would have been absolutely made up to meet another one a decade later.
A third connection between Virginia Padoana & Shakespeare again comes through wordplay. I sonnet 128, the second of the Dark Lady series, Shakespeare describes a woman playing a musical instrument called the virginals.
“How oft, when thou, my music, music play’st,
Upon that blessed wood whose motion sounds
With thy sweet fingers, when thou gently sway’st
The wiry concord that mine ear confounds …”
Could there be here a subtle play on Virginia’s name? After introducing the concept of the courtesan in the first of the Dark Lady sequence (sonnet 127), is he then cryptically naming in the second?
Fourthly, Virginia Padoana must have been at 30 years old, possibly older, & therefore the 23 year-old Shakespeare would have been something of a toyboy. Indeed, we have already seen him portray himself as a ‘baby’ in sonnet 143, & that she thinks him ‘some untutored youth,’ in sonnet 138.

A tantalising possibility is that the woman depicted in Parrasio Micheli’s Portrait of a Venetian Courtesan and Her Servant just shown may be Virginia Padoana. Micheli (c.1516–1578) was an active Venetian painter, associated with the artistic circles of Titian and Paolo Veronese. He belonged to an aristocratic family and was working in Venice during precisely the period of interest. He signed and dated his Self-Portrait Adoring the Dead Christ in 1573; in August 1575 he sent his Allegory of the Birth of Don Fernando to Philip II of Spain, accompanied by an explanation of its symbolism. His correspondence continued from Venice in 1576, placing the portrait around the time when Edward de Vere, Earl of Oxford, was travelling in Italy and visiting Venice. This means that she could be Virginia Padoana, & her dark hair & eyes means she could be Shakespeare’s Dark Lady. Perhaps….

Speculating further, the face of the model of Micheli’s ‘Portrait of a Venetian Courtesan and Her Servant’ possibly match that of the woman depicted in his ‘A Young Woman Playing a Lute.’ The difference is the hair colour, which does connect to Shakespeare’s Dark Lady using cosmetic dyes.
According to the Fondazione Zeri catalogue, Micheli painted three versions of Portrait of a Woman with a Lute, tentatively dated to 1570. The following version is currently being held at the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston.

This version I assume got to America via an auction at Christies, London, when ‘A Young Woman Playing a Mandolin,’ was sold on 27 June 1969, to a buyer recorded in the price list as “Spencer Sam.” This was probably Samuel Spencer (1910–1997), grandson of the American railway magnate Samuel Spencer (1847–1906), an art collector. The painting was consigned by Christies as “The property of a gentleman”, with no further provenance given. This, then, is the potential link to the Elizabethan gentry, & therefore the Earl of Oxford & Virginia Padoana. Perhaps…